MYGA vs Fixed Indexed Annuity: Which Produces More Guaranteed Income?

Episode 122 • November 12, 2026 • 00:16:46
MYGA vs Fixed Indexed Annuity: Which Produces More Guaranteed Income?
The Atlas Annuity Podcast
MYGA vs Fixed Indexed Annuity: Which Produces More Guaranteed Income?

Nov 12 2026 | 00:16:46

/

Hosted By

Marty Becker

Show Notes

Two annuity strategies. Same $500,000. Same five-year wait. One of them pays $250,000 less over 30 years.

In this episode I break down the question I get almost every week: if you're retiring in five years, should you fund a fixed indexed annuity with an income rider and lock in the guaranteed roll-ups — or put the money in a MYGA and buy a SPIA when the term ends?

Both strategies are built to do the same job. They do not produce the same result.

Using a 63-year-old couple retiring at 68:

That's $8,500 gone every single year — $171,000 lost over 20 years, $214,000 over 25, more than a quarter million over 30.

We also cover the difference nobody talks about: a rate tells you what your money will be worth. It tells you nothing about the income that money will buy. And the flexibility trade-off, because the MYGA does win in one honest way.

Then the part that matters most — starting with the job your money needs to do instead of starting with a product.

If you're within five years of retirement, book a retirement income clarity call at atlasannuity.com.

Educational purposes only. Not a recommendation to buy or sell any securities or insurance products. Always speak with a licensed advisor before purchasing any annuity or insurance product.

Short summary / snippet (for the Castos feed summary field, ~300 characters):

On $500,000, a fixed indexed annuity with an income rider pays $60,000 a year. A 6% MYGA grown for five years and converted to a SPIA pays $51,500. Same money, same wait — $250,000 less over 30 years. Here's the math.

Show notes / key takeaways block:

Links: atlasannuity.com — book a retirement income clarity call

Other Episodes

Episode 67

January 24, 2025 • 00:10:50
Episode Cover

Roth Conversion Annuity Update for 2025

Have you been considering a Roth conversion but aren’t sure how to handle the taxes or where to hold the funds? In this episode,...

Listen

Episode 86

September 13, 2025 • 00:15:06
Episode Cover

Why the 4% Rule Could Destroy Your Retirement

In episode 86 of the Atlas Annuity Podcast, Marty Becker takes a deep dive into systematic withdrawal plans and why they may not be...

Listen

Episode 37

August 13, 2024 • 00:27:53
Episode Cover

Debunking Dave Ramsey Annuity & Withdrawal Rate Advice

In this episode, we dive into a video made by Dave Ramsey where he talks about retirement withdrawal rates. We point out the problems...

Listen